Comments on: The Islamic view of Judaism

By: ِAyah

ِAyah — Wed, 05 Mar 2014 06:45:52 +0000

I was very happy to see this site at first, but now I am really disappointed. The website is called Judaism-Islam you should state the Islamic opinion as it is. Don’t alter it don’t change it. State the entire verse not only the part you like. I know what you said here about the islamic view is not accurate. Now, how can I trust That what you said about Judaism is true. A believer shouldn’t be afraid of comparing what he/she believes in to any other belief. A believer doesn’t lie about others’ believes to show what he/she believes in is correct. A believer should be honest and trustworthy, otherwise, he is not a true believer, he should stop misguiding people, and should start seeking the true truth for himself first.

By: Ustad

Ustad — Mon, 03 Mar 2014 17:20:16 +0000

A classic mixing of truth and lies; the end result is total falsehood. some Zionist is its author undoubtedly.

All previous scriptures were abrogated. They are no longer valid.

Adam, Noah, Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Jacob, Yousuf, Musa, Jesus, Mohammed (peace upon them all) and all other prophets and their true followers were and are all Muslims.

Those who deviated started Judaism and Christianity; Allah and his Messenger (pbuh)have nothing to do with them.

A cursory research of quran and sunnah reveals the above facts.

By: Raheli

Raheli — Mon, 03 Mar 2014 09:06:25 +0000

Obviously. you failed to read the page with understanding. No place are Jews required to “convert” (or revert) to Islam and follow the Quran. B’nai Yisrael was given the Torah. If we follow/obey it AS G-D intended us to, “we need have no fear in the day of Judgment”. Does that sound like you need to become Muslim?? We are specifically told otherwise. The following quote must be what you failed to read with comprehension, in order to be able to make your ignorant statement that “they would have mentioned shellfish” and “they’re trying to change us to Islam”. BTW, When G-D forbade shellfish, and gave the dietary law (Kashrut) to B’nai Yisrael, He said … “because you are am kadosh” (set apart, or holy). These laws were only given to the Jews, they’re not part of the Noachide Law, which exists in Islam No place does the Quran tell Jews to stop obeying the Torah!

“The Quran doesn’t replace the Torah

The Quran teaches that the word of God can never be altered, verifying the Jewish belief that the laws of the Torah stand for all time.

Quran 6:115
And the word of your Lord has been fulfilled in truth and in justice. None can alter His words, and He is the Hearing, the Knowing

The Quran never presented itself as a replacement to the Torah as the Jewish people were commanded to keep its laws forever. The Quran was sent as a guidance for mankind to live by and it was delivered to people capable of spreading the deen of Allah to the four corners of the earth.”

By: Follow-up

Follow-up — Fri, 27 Dec 2013 18:25:39 +0000

Please allow the previous comment to pass moderation even though it contradicts what I assume to be your purpose. The way of all Abrahamic faiths is a way of truth, respect, love, and openness.

By: Practical Jew

Practical Jew — Fri, 27 Dec 2013 18:21:41 +0000

As the comments show, this page is full of falsehoods meant to bring Jews to Islam. Were this page entirely accurate, the Muslims would also have the Torah prohibition on shellfish, they would join together to welcome all Jews to Israel, and they would transplant the Dome of the Rock so that Jews can worship in the Temple as the G-d of Abraham asks in the Torah. Islam and Judaism do not fully overlap.

By: LuisC

LuisC — Fri, 13 Sep 2013 20:25:17 +0000

Well, i see there’s a lot of people who hasn’t understood what this site is made for. Truly sad

By: al-magribi

al-magribi — Mon, 02 Sep 2013 22:30:08 +0000

Well, the ayat contradict you. In fact, 5:48 doesn’t just not indicate anything which would negates what has been pointed out in 5:21. It says that Allah “confirms that which proceeded it of the Scripture” (as 5:21 explicitly does that when it says that Allah gave the Holy Land to the Banu Yisrael).

Allah’s Message is the Truth. The Truth may not always be easy to accept, or even convenient for what it is that we want, but accepting the Truth is important if we wish to submit.

I think you’d do well to understand more about the practice of abrogation (may I recommend: http://www.lamppostproductions.com/abrogation-in-the-quran-shaykh-abdullah-bin-hamid-ali/ ). It’s practice is controversial and not only do not all of the Sunni madhabs follow it, but no two madhabs agree on which (if any) of the ayat are abrogated.

There is much at stake involved if we choose to believe that something has been abrogated that has not been. This is a very serious matter to engage in. To abrogate something that is not meant to be abrogated represents an undue distortion of the Message of Allah. This can lead people to act in ways that are a perversion of the Truth that Allah revealed to mankind.

There are many who would guide you to think that many of the things which Allah revealed to humanity have been abrogated. Allah knows best about their intentions and their understanding. But I think it’s important to draw an understanding that what Allah has reveals to humanity is the eternal Truth, and the judgments and scholarly opinions of the ulema are not universal or infallible.

It forces the question for us in where do we place our faith? Is it with the knowledge of men (scholars) or with the infallible Truth which Allah has revealed to humanity?

By: carrian13

carrian13 — Wed, 07 Aug 2013 00:11:45 +0000

This article makes no sense. Avraham was not a muslim. Religion did not start with Adam. The covenant was established first with Avraham and later through B’Nei Yisrael. None of the prophets were muslim. Only those who follow islam were muslim. Any the prophets surely did not follow the teachings of a quran.

By: servnat of god

servnat of god — Sun, 28 Jul 2013 16:44:30 +0000

no where the does quran explicitly state that allah gave the Israel to the jews. prophet Abraham was neither or jew or Christian. he was a muslim as all the prophets were muslim. allah does not accept a religion other than islam.
your taking verses out of context so no 1 can leave Judaism. not working.
the quran abrogates all previous scriptures. read 5:48 & other verses you quoted @ qtafsir.com